crave or save: ballard designs olivia mirrored side table

I've seen the UO table pop up on a few of my daily blog reads and I've been thinking about scooping it up - it would be perfect between two side chairs in our living room. Of course, I have yet to actually break down and buy it. Then, while I was flipping through the most recent Ballard Designs catalog I spotted a VERY similar table at twice the price. Besides the mirrored top I do not see any differences. I would pick the cheaper table everyday of the week.